Original Slept-On Cinema Alien vs. Predator (2004) review artwork: rival creatures at an icy pyramid

Alien vs. Predator (2004) Review: The Crossover Critics Hated and Fans Got Right

Alien vs. Predator is the crossover the fans asked for, with a title card that delighted both hosts. It closes the Slept-On Cinema triple feature, and the hosts call it "exactly what you wanted."

Paul W.S. Anderson's 2004 mash-up sits at 21% with critics and 39% with audiences. It also opened number one, knocked off Collateral, and made $177.5 million on a budget under $70 million. "This is not a movie for critics," Stan says. "This is a movie for fans." After Alien 3 and Predator 2, this is where the show lands.

The Slept-On Cinema Case

The hosts make their case through the creature work, practical sets, and fan service. Anderson came off Mortal Kombat and Resident Evil, shot on miniatures and practical sets in the last window before CGI took over, and the film still holds up on a big screen. It sits as a sequel to Predator 2 and a prequel to Alien, and the hosts think it found the one spot in both timelines where the crossover could work. The idea dates to a 1989 comic; the studio needed to line up two franchises to make it, and here it finally happened.

Spoilers from here: the Draft, BOLOs, fights, and finale details follow. Start with the episode’s spoiler-free first half if you have not watched yet.

The first pick

Stan takes the crossover itself, first overall: this is the movie version of mashing your G.I. Joes and Ninja Turtles together as a kid, and someone finally said "let's give the people what they want." Grobe takes the typography, both franchises' fonts on screen together, and argues Alien and Predator belong with Star Wars and Jurassic Park among the great title-card franchises.

Also drafted: the first facehugger leap 42 minutes in, shot in slow motion from multiple angles ("it's the first time every time"); the egg-laying, nasty in the best way; Lance Henriksen as Charles Bishop Weyland, grounding the franchise without repeating himself; Sanaa Lathan as Lex, whom the hosts compare to Ripley for sheer competence; the whaling-station history; and the 30-degree ice tube.

BOLOs

  • Cool intro text, a menacing satellite, the PSR, and ice climbing.
  • An incredible turtleneck worn in every temperature, a Raiders-style archaeology dig, and load-bearing face scars.
  • Great flashlights, flares, rope, coordinated jackets, and a cold alien (an ant farm, defrosting).
  • A hunter's moon, a penguin, a boomerang, whale bones, a pyramid, and using an alien as a shield.

Worth watching?

Yes, loudly. Superlative, favorite fight: unanimous for the first Alien-versus-Predator bout, the first time either host saw acid blood used as a weapon on purpose; honorable mention to the queen versus the water tower. Bumper stickers: "This whole thing was a trap" (Stan, for Range Rover owners) and "Want a piece of me, you ugly son of a bitch" (Grobe). One change to make it a blockbuster: make it R like the rest of both franchises, and, per Grobe, fix the Predator's fingers. Drink to pair: the shaved-ice martini from Grill 23 in Boston, or AMC's Trophy Hunter with Midori, pineapple, and Crystal Head vodka.

Production observation

Released August 13, 2004; $38.3 million opening weekend. The abandoned whaling station is historically accurate for turn-of-the-century Antarctica, which Stan spent an evening confirming. Spin-off pitches: the first-contact prequel where Predators teach humans to build pyramids, and Grobe's coming-of-age medieval Predator story, part Suburban Commando, part Road to Perdition. Next up on the show, by fan request: Cyborg, the first Van Damme movie in a while.

Keep the movie night going

FAQ

Is Alien vs. Predator (2004) worth watching?

Yes, especially after Alien 3 and Predator 2. It's a fast, practical-effects crossover that delivers every matchup fans argued about for fifteen years.

Where does Alien vs. Predator fit in the timeline?

It's a sequel to Predator 2 and a prequel to Alien, set in present-day Antarctica with Lance Henriksen as the founder of Weyland.

Was Alien vs. Predator a flop?

No. It opened number one and earned about $177 million worldwide on a budget of $60 to $70 million.

Become a Movie Optimist

If you like movies more than algorithms, join the Reappraisal Club for fresh arguments, BOLOs, Draft picks, and better movie-night choices.

JOIN FREE · Enter the Movie Optimist Vault

Back to blog